Menu Engineering: Transforming Your Restaurant's Bottom Line

Imagine boosting your restaurant’s profits by 10-15% without increasing foot traffic or compromising food quality. This isn’t a pipe dream—it’s the tangible result of effective menu engineering. In an industry where profit margins often hover around 3-5%, creating a profitable restaurant menu through menu engineering is a game-changing strategy that can dramatically impact your bottom line. By leveraging data-driven insights and psychological principles, this powerful approach transforms your restaurant’s menu back from a simple list of dishes into a strategic tool for maximizing profitability. Whether you’re running a cozy neighbourhood bistro or a bustling chain restaurant, mastering the art and science of menu engineering can be the difference between merely surviving and truly thriving in the competitive culinary landscape. Let’s dive into how you can harness this potential to not only meet but exceed your financial goals while enhancing the dining experience for your customers through effective menu optimization.

What is Menu Engineering?

Menu engineering is a sophisticated, data-driven approach that combines culinary artistry with business acumen to optimize restaurant profitability. This strategic analytical process, first introduced by Michigan State University professors in the 1980s, has evolved into an essential tool for modern restaurateurs within the restaurant industry. By meticulously analyzing sales data, food costs, and customer preferences, menu engineering allows restaurant operators to make informed decisions and more profitable menus that can significantly impact their bottom line. Additionally, menu engineering contributes to menu optimization by ensuring that every item on the menu is strategically placed to maximize profitability and customer satisfaction.

The Science Behind the Menu

Menu engineering is not just about rearranging dishes on a page; it’s a multidisciplinary approach to menu redesign that incorporates menu engineering analysis, layout and menu analysis:

• Marketing psychology: Understanding how customers read menus and make decisions
• Behavioural economics: Applying principles like anchoring and decoy pricing and analyzing menu prices to influence customer choices
• Data analytics: Utilizing advanced software to track and analyze sales patterns
• Culinary trends: Staying attuned to evolving food preferences and dietary requirements
• Menu psychology: Understanding how design elements like currency symbols, colours, and descriptive language influence customer choices

Menu analysis helps to understand customer behaviour and optimizes the menu layout.

For example, the Cheesecake Factory, known for its extensive and profitable menu items, uses menu engineering principles to maintain profitability across its vast array of offerings. They strategically place high-margin items in the “sweet spots” of their menu layout, which are typically the upper right corner and center of the menu.

Key Concepts in Menu Engineering

Menu Item's Popularity and Profitability

These two dimensions form the cornerstone of menu engineering and menu analysis. Popularity is typically measured by the number of units sold over the average customer’s spending over a specific period, while each item’s contribution margin determines profitability.

Analyzing the popularity and profitability of promoted menu items helps in making data-driven decisions to adjust the restaurant menu for better performance. Analyzing the menu item’s food cost prices in relation to food cost percentage and customer preferences can further optimize the menu performance and profitability of each menu item.

Four Menu Engineering Categories

1. Stars: High profitability and high popularity. Example: A signature dish like Nobu’s Black Cod with Miso, which is both popular and highly profitable
2. Plow-Horses: Low profitability but high popularity. Example: A classic Caesar salad that sells well but has a lower profit margin due to ingredient costs
3. Puzzles: High profitability but low popularity. Example: A high-end caviar dish that generates significant profit per sale but isn’t ordered frequently
4. Dogs: Low profitability and low popularity. Example: A dated menu item that neither sells well nor contributes much to the bottom line

The menu engineering matrix helps calculate food costs by categorizing menu items into four categories, allowing restaurant owners to make informed decisions about pricing and menu design.

Determining menu item prices, profitability, and contribution margins is a critical process for any restaurant owner and operator to optimize their financial performance. Here’s a detailed breakdown of how to approach this:

Determining Menu Item Prices

There are several methods to determine menu item prices:

1. Food Cost Percentage Method:

• Set a target food cost percentage, typically between 25-40%.
• Calculate the menu price using this formula: Menu Price = Raw Food Cost / Target Food Cost Percentage.

For example, if a dish costs $5 to make and your target food cost is 30%: Menu Price = $5 / 0.30 = $16.67

1. Gross Profit Margin Method:

• Choose your desired gross profit margin percentage.
• Use this formula: Ideal Gross Profit Margin = (Menu Price - Raw Food Cost) / Menu Price.

For instance, if you want a 72% gross profit margin and the raw food cost is $4: 0.72 = (Menu Price - $4) / Menu Price. Solving this equation gives a menu price of $14.50

1. Competitive Analysis:

• Research competitor prices for similar items.
• Price your items competitively while ensuring profitability.

Menu pricing strategies can also be used to determine the best prices for menu items by analyzing various factors such as food costs, desired profit margins, and competitor pricing.

Calculating Profitability

Menu profitability of menu items is typically assessed on restaurant menus using two key metrics:

1. Food Cost Percentage: Food Cost Percentage = (Total Cost of Dish Per Serving / Price of Dish to Customer) x 100Lower food cost percentages generally indicate higher profitability. The industry standard is between 25% and 40%.
2. Contribution Margin: Contribution Margin = Selling Price - Food Cost. This shows how much each item contributes to covering fixed costs and generating profit. Higher contribution margins indicate more profitable items.

Determining Contribution Margins

To calculate menu contribution margins:

1. Calculate the food cost for each menu item.
2. Subtract the food cost from the selling price.

For example:

• If a steak sells for $45 and costs $25 to make, the contribution margin is $20.

It’s important to calculate the contribution margin for each menu item. This allows you to:

1. Compare items: Items with higher contribution margins are generally more profitable.
2. Calculate the average contribution margin (ACM): ACM = Total Contribution Margin / Total Number of Items Sold
3. Categorize menu items:

• Stars: High profitability (above ACM) and high popularity
• Plow-Horses: Low profitability (below ACM) but high popularity
• Puzzles: High profitability but low popularity
• Dogs: Low profitability and low popularity

Using This Information

1. Menu Engineering: Use these metrics to optimize your menu. For example:

• Promote high contribution margin items
• Consider repricing or removing low contribution margin items
• Redesign the menu to highlight profitable items

1. Pricing Strategies: Adjust prices based on contribution margins and food cost percentages. For instance, slightly increasing prices on popular items with low contribution margins can significantly impact overall profitability.
2. Cost Control: Identify items with high food costs and look for ways to reduce them without compromising quality.
3. Menu Mix: Aim for a balanced menu with a mix of high and low-food-cost items, ensuring that you’re meeting your target food cost percentage and profitability goals overall.
4. Continuous Monitoring: Regularly analyze these metrics and adjust your menu accordingly. Market conditions, ingredient costs, and customer preferences change over time, so your menu should evolve as well. Menu optimization strategies can be used to continuously improve the menu by regularly assessing and adjusting based on these metrics.

By systematically analyzing and optimizing menu item prices, profitability, and contribution margins, restaurant operators can significantly increase menu profitability and enhance their financial performance while meeting customer expectations.

Critical Metrics

Food Cost Percentage: Ideally, this should be between 28% and 35% for the menu costing most restaurants. Fine dining establishments might aim for 22-28%, while quick-service restaurants might target 25-30%.

Menu Metrics: Food cost percentage and contribution margin are critical menu metrics. Contribution Margin: This metric helps identify which items are truly driving profitability profitable restaurant menus. For instance, a $20 dish with a $5 food cost has a contribution margin of $15. Setting menu prices based on these metrics ensures that each item contributes to overall profitability.

The 6 Steps in the Menu Engineering Process

1. Menu Item Analysis

Utilize advanced POS systems like Toast or TouchBistro to gather comprehensive data on menu item popularity and performance. These systems can provide detailed reports on sales volume, revenue, and even time-of-day popularity for each dish.

2. Categorizing Menu Items

Create a menu engineering matrix using spreadsheet software like Excel or Google Sheets, focusing on menu item categorization. Plot each menu item's food cost in the menu matrix based on its popularity and profitability, visually representing its category.

3. Menu Design and Layout

Implement menu design principles backed by eye-tracking studies, such as those conducted by Dr. Sybil Yang at San Francisco State University. These studies have shown that customers tend to read menus in a “Z” pattern, making the top right corner a prime location for high-profit items. A well-crafted menu description can further entice customers to choose these items.

4. Menu Pricing and Redesign

Use great menu description and pricing techniques like charm pricing (ending prices with .99) or price anchoring (placing expensive items with great menu descriptions near moderately priced ones to make the latter seem more reasonable) when setting menu prices.

5. Online Menu Engineering

Optimize your digital presence by ensuring that all your menu items are mobile-friendly and integrate seamlessly with popular food delivery platforms like Uber Eats or DoorDash.

Digital menu optimization can enhance the online presence of a restaurant by making it easier for customers to find and order from your menu.

6. Monitoring and Adjusting

Implement a quarterly review cycle to assess menu performance metrics and make data-driven adjustments. Use A/B testing for new menu designs or pricing strategies to determine the most effective approach.

Advanced Techniques in Menu Engineering

Menu Engineering Worksheet

Develop a comprehensive menu worksheet that includes the following:

• Item name and description
• Sales volume
• Menu prices
• Food cost
• Labour cost
• Contribution margin
• Food cost percentage
• Category (Star, Plow-Horse, Puzzle, Dog)

Profitable Menu Item Promotion

Implement targeted marketing strategies, such as menu item promotion, to increase sales for high-margin items. For example, train staff to recommend these dishes or feature them prominently on social media platforms.

Separate Menus for Special Services

Create special event menus for occasions like Valentine’s Day or New Year’s Eve, featuring premium ingredients and higher price points to maximize profitability and popularity during peak periods.

Portion Control and Food Waste Management

Implement inventory management systems like MarketMan or Orderly to track ingredient usage and minimize waste. Consider using pre-portioned ingredients for consistent serving sizes and cost control.

Menu Item Descriptions

Craft compelling menu descriptions using descriptive menu language and sensory language. For example, instead of “Grilled Chicken Breast,” use “Herb-Crusted Free-Range Chicken, Fire-Grilled to Juicy Perfection.”

‍